Logo image
Methodological threat or myth?: Evaluating the current state of evidence on common method variance in human resource management research
Journal article   Open access   Peer reviewed

Methodological threat or myth?: Evaluating the current state of evidence on common method variance in human resource management research

Nikos Bozionelos and Marcia J. Simmering
Human Resource Management Journal, Vol.32(1), pp.194-215
01/01/2022

Abstract

Major methodological topic common method variance common method bias post hoc methods evidence Simulations reviews coefficients distortion estimates
New key evidence on common method variance (CMV) has been generated in the last decade (including quantitative and qualitative reviews, and simulations) to estimate its real validity threat, and evaluate the post hoc techniques to detect and correct for its effects. This work looks at the new evidence, and reviews all HRM-related empirical articles published in the last 10 years in six major journals. The following primary conclusions are drawn. First, adoption of new knowledge about CMV by the empirical literature has been uneven. Second, published research in these journals indicates few incidences of meaningful distortion of estimates due to CMV, even when post hoc tests are used to detect it. Third, these findings in the empirical literature mirror the conclusions of reviews and simulations of the last 10 years, which indicate that the probability of significant distortion of estimates because of CMV is very limited.
pdf
HRMJ-CMVCurrentStateofEvidence_Bozionelos&Simmering_AcceptedManuscriptVersionDownloadView
Open Access
pdf
HRMJ_Bozionelos_202201
Restricted Access

Metrics

81 File views/ downloads
17 Record Views

Details

InCites Highlights

These are selected metrics from InCites Benchmarking & Analytics tool, related to this contribution

Collaboration types
Domestic collaboration
International collaboration
Citation topics
6 Social Sciences
6.3 Management
6.3.48 Organizational Behavior
Web of Science research areas
Industrial Relations & Labor
Management
Logo image